Bennie's Famous Tomato Pie

Come get a slice! Or two... Or eight....

Freshly Baked Italian Bread & Rolls

Everything Tastes BETTA On A Bennie's!

True Neopolitan Pizza

Cooked To Order In A 750° Wood Fired Brick Oven

Try One Of Our Delicious Sandwiches

Hot and Cold Sandwiches Available

Eat In or Take Home

Indoor Seating Available Year-Round & Cafe Style Outdoor Seating Available Seasonally

Breakfast Sandwiches

Served On A Famous Bennie Roll Or A Homemade Bagel. Daily Until 11:30 am

Tasty Pastries, Cakes and Pies

Fresh Filled Cannolis, Sfogliatelli, Tiramisu & More All Baked On The Premises

Pick Up a Gift Certificate

Giving is the greatest gift anyone can receive. Why not make it BETTA with a Bennie’s Bread and Italian Market Gift Certificate? Order here or in person.

Gluten-Free Options

We have gluten free prepared foods and pastry options. Call us for current items and availability.

Daily Blackboard Specials

Click here to stay up to date with our Daily Specials.

Call Ahead For Fast Take Out

609-398-9450

Signup For Our Newsletter!

Freshly Baked Daily

• Dinner Rolls
• Bennie Rolls
• Hoagie Rolls
• Round Rolls
• Wheat Rolls

• Rye Rolls*
• Pumpernickel Rolls*

• Fresh Homemade Bagels Made Daily!*

* To ensure availability of this item, please call and order with at least 24 hours notice.

• Sesame Seeded Semolina
• Wheat Loaf
• Large Italian Loaf
• Stick Loaf
• Sesame Seeded Twist
• Poppy Seeded Twist

• Rye Loaf*
• Pumpernickel Loaf*
• Cinnamon Raisin Bread*
• Ciabatta*
• Multi-grain Loaf*

• Olive Bread*
• Pizza Bread*
• Cranberry Walnut Loaf*
• Rosemary Garlic Flatbread*

Stuffed Breads
• Pepperoni & Cheese
• Sausage, Sweet Peppers & Cheese
• Meatball Parm

• Spinach, Tomato & Cheese
• Three Cheese Buffalo Chicken