Skip to main content

Bennie’s 12th Street Menu

Call 609.398.9450 To Order

 1159 Asbury Avenue

Family Dinners

All family dinners serve 4 people – Served in aluminum trays for easy reheating

Penne and Meatballs in Bennie’s Homemade Gravy – $34.99

Chicken Parm w/ Pasta – $49.99

Soup & Salad

Choice of Dressing: Creamy Italian, Balsamic Vinaigrette or Oil & Vinegar

*Comes with 1 Dressing Cup – Additional Dressing $1.00

*Add Grilled Chicken to Any Salad for $5.00

Soup of the Day – Pint $5.99

Caesar – $9.99

Romaine Lettuce with Shaved Parmesan and Homemade Croutons

Greens – $9.99

Spring Mix Lettuce, Vine Ripe Tomato, Cucumber, Shaved Parmesan & Balsamic Vinaigrette

Hot Sandwiches

All Sandwiches Are Made to Order On a Bennie’s 9″ Hoagie Roll

Add Broccoli Rabe Or Roasted Long Hot Peppers To Any Sandwich For $1 Each

Chicken Breast Cutlet – $11.99

Hormone & Antibiotic-Free, Breaded in Seasoned Crumbs w/ Sharp Provolone

Grilled Chicken Breast – $12.99

Greens, Roasted Tomato & Parmesan Aioli

Meatball Parm – $10.99

Homemade Meatballs & Sauce With A Flavorful Blend Of Cheeses

Eggplant Parm – $10.99

Homemade Meatballs & Sauce With A Flavorful Blend Of Cheeses

Chicken Parm – $12.99

Hormone and Antibiotic Free Chicken Breaded in Homemade Breadcrumbs & Sauce With A Flavorful Blend Of Cheeses

Pork Shoulder – $10.99

*Add Broccoli Rabe or Long Hots for $1.50 each*

Seasoned & Roasted Low & Slow Until Tender With Sharp Provolone

Italian Sausage, Peppers & Onion – $9.99

Sweet Or Hot Sausage

“Parm It”  With Sauce & Mozzarella – Add $2

Cold Sandwiches

All Sandwiches Are Made To Order On A Bennie’s 9″ Hoagie Roll

Have Any Cold Sandwich Made Into A Salad On A Bed Of Mixed Greens & Choice Of Dressing For An Additional $2

Grilled Vegetables – $10.99

Eggplant, Zucchini, Peppers, Onions, Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Tomato

The “Real Deal” Italian – $11.99

Cappacolla, Genoa Salami, Parma Prosciutto, Provolone & Tomato Bruschetta

Vine Ripe Tomato – $8.99

Jersey (When Available), Fresh Mozzarella, Basil & Evoo
Add Parma Prosciutto – $3

Italian Style Tuna – $9.99

(No Mayo) – Romaine, Marinated Artichokes, Tomato, Balsamic, Basil & Evoo (Available Seasonally)

True Neopolitan Pizzas

12 Inch Handmade & Cooked To Order In A Wood Fired Brick Oven

Dough is Made On Premise With Double 00 Artisan Flour

Add Prosciutto di Parma to any pizza for an additional $3

*Any of our pizzas can be made on a Gluten Free crust for an additional $5.00*


Margherita – $12.99

Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella & Basil, Finished with Extra Virgin Olive Oil and Grated Locatelli

California – $13.99

Sauce, Roasted Red Peppers, Olives, Goat Cheese, & Topped w/Arugula

Sozzeech! – $12.99

Sauce, Mozzarella, Sweet Italian Sausage & Oregano


Quattro D’formaggio – $13.99

Mozzarella, Ricotta, Grated Locatelli, Asiago, Olive Oil, Garlic & Oregano

Caprese – $13.99

Fresh Mozzarella, Roma Tomato, Grated Locatelli, Basil & Evoo

Grilled Veggie Pizza – $14.99

Grilled Zucchinni, Eggplant, Red Peppers and Onions with Mozzarella and Asiago Cheeses with garlic and oil, No Sauce

Bennie’s Italian Specialties

Everything Homemade!

Chicken Cutlets

Hormone & Antibiotic Free Chicken Breast Hand-Breaded In Our Homemade Bennie’s Bread Crumbs

Eggplant Cutlets

Fresh Eggplant Thinly Sliced & Hand-Breaded In Our Homemade Bennie’s Bread Crumbs


Freshly Made Layered Pasta With Homemade Red Sauce, Ricotta Cheese, Fresh Basil & Sweet Italian Sausage.
* Vegetarian Lasagna Available; One Day Advance Notice Required


Homemade Risotto Rice Ball Mixed With Cheese With A Center Of Sweet Italian Sausage, Sweet Peas & Onions

Eggplant Parmesan

Grandma’s Recipe! Our Freshly Made Eggplant Cutlets Layered With Homemade Red Sauce, Mozzarella & Grated Locatelli

Homemade Meatballs

Beef & Pork Mixture With Our Homemade Breadcrumbs, Italian Seasonings & Locatelli Cheese

Hormone & Antibiotic Free Grilled Chicken Breast
Eggplant Parmesan

Roasted Red & Yellow Tomatoes
Grilled Vegetables
Italian Olive Salad
Fresh Mozzarella
Tortellini Salad
White Bean Salad
Long Hot Peppers
Broccoli Rabe

Italian Seafood Salad
Roasted Red Peppers
Pepper Shooters
Fresh Bruschetta

Italian Bakery Specialties

* – Gluten Free Item

Stuffed Breads

Pepperoni & Cheese
Sausage, Sweet Peppers & Cheese
Spinach, Tomato & Cheese
Meatball Parmesan
Buffalo Chicken

Italian Pastries

Fresh Filled Cannolis
Cream Puffs
Mini Chocolate Tortes*


Bennie’s Famous Tomato Pie
Homemade Spinach Artichoke Dip*

Cakes & Pies

Italian Rum Cake
Cheese Cake
Hot Milk Pound Cake
Homemade Ricotta Cheese Cake*
Sour Cream Coffee Cake
Chocolate Thunder Cake
Carrot Cake

Baked Goods

Italian Cookies
Assorted Muffins
Crumb Cake
Homemade Biscotti

Coffee Bar


Bennie’s Bread

Breakfast Sandwiches Served Daily Until 1 pm
Brick Oven Pizzas Served Daily From 11 am 

Freshly Baked Bread Served All Day!

1159 Asbury Avenue • Ocean City, NJ 08226



340 Ocean Avenue • Ocean City, NJ 08226