Bennie’s will be open during its normal operating hours:

Fridays and Saturdays: 8 am – 6 pm Sundays: 8 am – 4 pm

Bennie’s will be open during these hours for Curbside Pick-up ONLY and be offering a limited menu (Please See Below). Please call 609.398.9450 to place your order. Please have credit card ready – We will be processing your card at time of pickup – No cash will be accepted.

Thank you for your continued support during this time.

EASTER BREAD!! $5.99/each

Breakfast Sandwiches

Served Until 1 pm

Bacon, Sausage OR Porkroll Only – $4.99
Bacon, Sausage OR Porkroll w/ Cheese – $4.99
Egg Sandwich – $3.49
Egg and Cheese Sandwich – $3.99
Bacon, Sausage OR Porkroll w/ Egg and Cheese – $4.99

Grocery Items

For your convenience, Bennie’s will temporarily be carrying the following items:

Whole Milk – $4.25/Gallon
Butter (1 lb) – $3.99
Dozen Eggs – $2.99

New! Family Dinners!

All Family Dinners Serve 4 people – No Substitutions, Please!

• Chicken Parmesan w/ Penne and a Stick Loaf – $34.99
• Penne w/ Gravy, Meatballs and a Stick Loaf – $24.99 • Whole Roasted Chicken w/ Green Beans and Mashed Potatoes – $34.99 • Meatloaf w/ Green Beans and Mashed Potatoes – $39.99
• Pan Seared Salmon w/ Green Beans and Mashed Potatoes – $44.99

Soup & Salad

Choice of Dressing: Creamy Italian, Balsamic Vinaigrette or Oil & Vinegar

Soup of the Day – Quart $10.99

Garden – $6.99

Mixed Lettuce, Grape Tomato, Cucumber, Carrot, Roasted Red Onion & Choice Of Dressing

Greens – $7.99

Spring Mix Lettuce, Vine Ripe Tomato, Cucumber, Shaved Parmesan & Balsamic Vinaigrette

Hot Sandwiches

All Sandwiches Are Made to Order On a Bennie’s 9″ Hoagie Roll

Add Broccoli Rabe, Grilled Red Peppers OR Roasted Long Hot Peppers To Any Sandwich For $1.50

Chicken Breast Cutlet – $8.99

Hormone & Antibiotic-Free, Breaded in Seasoned Crumbs w/ Sharp Provolone

Grilled Chicken Breast – $8.99

Greens, Roasted Tomato & Parmesan Aioli

Meatball Parm – $7.99

Homemade Meatballs & Sauce With A Flavorful Blend Of Cheeses

Pork Shoulder – $8.99

Seasoned & Roasted Low & Slow Until Tender With Sharp Provolone

Italian Sausage, Peppers & Onion – $8.99

Sweet Or Hot Sausage

“Parm It”  With Sauce & Mozzarella – Add $2

Grilled Chicken Special – $9.99

Arugula, Chipotle Aioli and Asiago Cheese

BBQ Pork – $9.99

Sweet BBQ Sauce, Cheddar Cheese and Grilled Red Onions

Cold Sandwiches

All Sandwiches Are Made To Order On A Bennie’s 9″ Hoagie Roll

Have Any Cold Sandwich Made Into A Salad On A Bed Of Mixed Greens & Choice Of Dressing For An Additional $2

Grilled Vegetables – $9.99

Eggplant, Zucchini, Peppers, Onions, Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Tomato

The “Real Deal” Italian – $8.99

Cappacolla, Genoa Salami, Parma Prosciutto, Provolone & Tomato Bruschetta

Vine Ripe Tomato – $6.99

Jersey (When Available), Fresh Mozzarella, Basil & Evoo
Add Parma Prosciutto – $3

Italian Style Tuna – $7.99

(No Mayo) – Romaine, Marinated Artichokes, Tomato, Balsamic, Basil & Evoo (Available Seasonally)

True Neopolitan Pizzas

12 Inch Handmade & Cooked To Order In A Wood Fired Brick Oven

Dough is Made On Premise With Double 00 Artisan Flour

Add Prosciutto di Parma to any pizza for an additional $3

*Any of our pizzas can be made on a Gluten Free crust for an additional $3.50*


Margherita – $10.99

Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella & Basil, Finished with Extra Virgin Olive Oil and Grated Locatelli

California – $11.99

Sauce, Roasted Red Peppers, Olives, Goat Cheese, & Topped w/Arugula

Sozzeech! – $10.99

Sauce, Mozzarella, Sweet Italian Sausage & Oregano


Quattro D’formaggio – $11.99

Mozzarella, Ricotta, Grated Locatelli, Asiago, Olive Oil, Garlic & Oregano

Caprese – $11.99

Fresh Mozzarella, Roma Tomato, Grated Locatelli, Basil & Evoo

Grilled Vegetable – $12.99

Grilled Red Peppers, Zucchini, Eggplant, Red Onion and Roasted Tomatoes w/ Asiago and Mozzarella Cheeses Topped w/ Fresh Basil

Bennie’s Italian Specialties

Everything Homemade!

Chicken Cutlets – $11.99/lb
Grilled Chicken – $11.99/lb
Eggplant Cutlets – $10.99/lb
Grilled Vegetables – $10.99/lb
Eggplant Parm – $9.99/lb
Arancini – $10.99/lb

Crab Bites – $29.99/lb
Homemade Meatballs – $9.99/lb
Lasagna w/ Sweet Italian Sausage – $7.99/lb
Meatloaf – $9.99/lb
Chicken Pot Pie – $9.99/each
Grilled Vegetables – $10.99/lb

Fresh Mozzarella – $8.99/each
White Bean Salad – $7.99/lb

Pepper Shooters – $9.99/lb
Roasted Red Peppers – $12.99/lb
Chicken Salad – $10.99/lb
Chicken Waldorf Salad – $10.99/lb
Tuna Salad – $9.99/lb
Macaroni Salad – $6.99/lb
Potato Salad – $6.99/lb

Ask About Your Favorite Item – It May Be Available!

Italian Bakery Specialties

EASTER BREADS! $5.99/each

Stuffed Breads

Pepperoni & Cheese – $9.99
Spinach, Tomato & Cheese – $9.99
Meatball Parm – $10.99
Sausage, Sweet Peppers & Cheese – $9.99

Italian Pastries

Fresh Filled Cannolis – $2/small – $3.50/large
Cream Puffs – $.60/each
Eclairs – $2.50/each
Mini Chocolate Tortes (GF) – $1/each


Bennie’s Famous Tomato Pie – $2.00/slice
Homemade Spinach Artichoke Dip OR Buffalo Chicken Dip – $9.99/lb

Cakes & Pies

Italian Rum Cake – $16.99
Cheese Cake – $24.99
Hot Milk Pound Cake – $24.99/whole – $13/half
Sour Cream Coffee Cake – $24.99/whole – $13/half
Chocolate Thunder Cake – $3.99/slice
Carrot Cake – $24.99

Baked Goods

Danish – $2.50/each
Italian Cookies – $11.99/lb
Assorted Muffins – $2.50/each
Crumb Cake – $2.50/each
Homemade Biscotti – $11.99/lb
Cinnamon Rolls – $3.99 each
Raspberry Filled or Chocolate Filled Shortbread Cookies – $1.50/each

Coffee Bar


Bennie’s Bread

Bennie’s Rolls or Round Rolls – $.70/each – $7.99/dozen
Bagels – $1.00/each $10.99/dozen
Stick Loaf – $1.99/each
Seeded Semolina Loaf – $3.50/each

Ask About Any Additional Items Available!